News

LEGAL INSIGHT. Mediation in Commercial Disputes: Solutions Beyond the Courtroom. Part 1

Andrey Nekrasov, Managing Partner of NRP, attorney and mediator, explains how mediation helped resolve a major accounts receivable dispute in a situation where the legal prospects were clear to both sides, but a court judgment would not have addressed their commercial interests.

“In commercial disputes, it often seems that if the legal position is strong, the next step is obvious: a formal demand, a claim, and a court judgment. In practice, things can be more complicated.

Recently, I conducted a series of corporate mediations involving substantial accounts receivable disputes. In these matters, the suppliers had performed their obligations, the goods had been delivered and accepted, and from a legal perspective the claims for payment of the principal debt were relatively straightforward. The amounts involved were significant, running into hundreds of millions of rubles. Formally, the creditor could have gone to court and would most likely have obtained a judgment for the outstanding debt and contractual penalties. But a court victory does not always solve the underlying business problem.

The creditor needs to receive the money, preferably not a year or two later after several levels of court proceedings, but within a reasonable and predictable timeframe. The debtor, in turn, may understand that payment must be made, yet be unable to process it in the ordinary way because of internal corporate, budgetary or organisational constraints. At the same time, the parties may still be interested in continuing their business relationship. This is precisely where mediation can create room for a solution.

A court answers legal questions: does the obligation exist, has it been breached, and what amount should be awarded? Mediation allows the parties to ask a different question: what outcome do they actually need, and can they design a solution that works for the business?

In one category of disputes I handled, the scope for compromise arose around penalties. The creditor could claim both the principal debt and additional contractual sanctions. For the debtor, however, the continuing increase in the overall amount due made settlement more difficult. The negotiations therefore focused on a structure under which the creditor would waive part of the additional claims in exchange for payment of the principal debt on agreed terms. For one side, the value lay in speed and certainty. For the other, it lay in preventing the debt from increasing further and avoiding litigation.

In disputes of this kind, the value of mediation does not lie in simply finding a midpoint between the parties’ original demands. It allows the parties to identify which terms matter most to each of them and, on that basis, construct a solution that would not ordinarily be available through a court judgment. For one party, the priority may be receiving the principal debt sooner. For the other, it may be limiting further financial exposure, preserving a supplier relationship or continuing a project. It is precisely these differences in priorities that can create room for agreement.

This is one of the key features of mediation: the parties can exchange terms that have different value to each of them and design a settlement structure that responds to their actual business objectives".

Andrey Nekrasov
Managing Partner, NRP, PhD in Law, Attorney, Mediator

This material is for informational purposes only and does not constitute individual legal advice.

In Part 2, Andrey Nekrasov will explain how commercial mediation works in practice and what opportunities it can offer businesses beyond a court judgment.